How to Find the Best Breweries in Indianapolis

Indianapolis has undergone a remarkable transformation in its craft beer scene over the past decade. Once known primarily for its motorsports heritage and midwestern charm, the city has emerged as a thriving hub for innovative brewers, experimental flavors, and community-driven taprooms. Whether you're a local looking to explore new favorites or a visitor planning a beer-focused itinerary, knowing how to find the best breweries in Indianapolis can elevate your experience from casual sipping to authentic cultural immersion. This guide provides a comprehensive, step-by-step approach to identifying top-tier breweries, understanding what sets them apart, and leveraging the right tools to make informed decisions. With over 60 craft breweries operating in the metro area, the key isn't just finding any brewery—it’s discovering the ones that align with your taste, values, and experience goals.

Step-by-Step Guide

Define Your Beer Preferences

Before diving into lists or maps, take a moment to reflect on what kind of beer experience you’re seeking. Do you prefer hop-forward IPAs with citrus and pine notes? Or are you drawn to rich, roasty stouts with chocolate and coffee undertones? Maybe you enjoy sour ales with tart fruit profiles or traditional lagers with crisp clean finishes. Your personal palate is the foundation of your brewery search. Consider making a short list of your favorite styles and flavor profiles. This will help you filter through the overwhelming number of options and focus on breweries known for excelling in those categories.

For example, if you love barrel-aged beers, prioritize breweries with dedicated aging programs. If you value sustainability and locally sourced ingredients, seek out those that highlight partnerships with regional farms or use solar power. Defining your preferences doesn’t limit your options—it sharpens them, ensuring you spend your time at places that genuinely resonate with your tastes.

Use Online Beer Databases and Review Platforms

Modern technology offers powerful tools to uncover hidden gems and validate popular choices. Platforms like Untappd, BeerAdvocate, and RateBeer are indispensable for researching brewery reputations. Untappd, in particular, is widely used by Indianapolis beer enthusiasts and provides real-time check-ins, user ratings, and detailed tasting notes. Search for breweries in Indianapolis and sort by highest-rated or most-checked-in locations. Look beyond the top 10—many excellent breweries have smaller followings but consistently high ratings from loyal patrons.

Pay attention to the language in reviews. Phrases like “consistently excellent,” “innovative seasonal releases,” or “best pastry stout in the state” signal quality and reliability. Avoid relying solely on aggregate scores; read a handful of recent reviews to understand if a brewery’s offerings have evolved or declined. Also, check for photos uploaded by users—this gives you a visual sense of the taproom atmosphere, glassware, and presentation, all indicators of a brewery’s attention to detail.

Explore Local Beer Blogs and Publications

While national beer publications cover big trends, local voices often provide the most accurate and nuanced insights. Indianapolis-based blogs like Indianapolis Monthly’s Beer Column, On Tap Indy, and Beer in the Burbs regularly feature in-depth brewery profiles, interviews with brewers, and seasonal roundups. These sources don’t just list names—they explain why a brewery matters. For instance, a blog might detail how a local brewery revived a forgotten German lager style using heritage yeast strains, or how they partnered with a nearby coffee roaster to create a limited-run cold brew stout.

Subscribe to newsletters or follow these blogs on social media. Many feature “Brewery of the Month” spotlights or weekend taproom event previews. These aren’t advertisements—they’re curated recommendations from people who visit breweries weekly and have deep knowledge of the local scene.

Visit Brewery Websites and Social Media

A brewery’s website and social media presence are strong indicators of professionalism, transparency, and passion. Top-tier breweries maintain active Instagram and Facebook accounts, posting daily updates on new releases, taproom hours, food truck schedules, and live music events. Look for consistency—do they post regularly? Are the photos high-quality and authentic? Do they respond to comments and questions?

On their websites, check for detailed descriptions of their core and seasonal beers. A brewery that lists ABV, IBU, ingredients, and flavor notes demonstrates a commitment to educating its customers. Also, look for information about their brewing philosophy. Do they emphasize small-batch production? Do they use local grains or hops? Are they involved in community initiatives? These details reveal whether a brewery is a genuine part of the local ecosystem or merely a commercial operation.

Check for Awards and Industry Recognition

While awards aren’t everything, they do serve as third-party validation of quality. Look for breweries that have won medals at prestigious competitions like the Great American Beer Festival (GABF), the World Beer Cup, or the Indiana Brewers Cup. Indianapolis breweries such as Sun King Brewery and Upland Brewing Company have consistently earned accolades across multiple categories, from Best American-Style Pale Ale to Best Fruit Beer.

Don’t dismiss smaller breweries without national recognition, however. Many excellent operations compete locally and are celebrated by regional panels. The Indiana Brewers Cup, for example, is judged by industry professionals and experienced homebrewers, making it a highly respected local benchmark. A brewery that wins multiple medals here is likely delivering exceptional quality, even if it hasn’t broken into the national spotlight yet.

Visit Taprooms in Person

No amount of online research replaces the experience of walking into a taproom. The best way to find the best breweries in Indianapolis is to go there yourself. Start with a few top contenders from your research and plan a weekend tour. Pay attention to the staff’s knowledge—do they enthusiastically explain the beers, suggest pairings, or ask about your preferences? Are the taps clean and well-labeled? Is the space inviting, clean, and thoughtfully designed?

Try at least three different beers on draft. Compare them side by side. Is one noticeably more balanced or complex? Does the carbonation feel right? Is the flavor true to style? Take notes. You might discover that a brewery you thought was overrated on paper delivers an unexpectedly brilliant sour, or that a quiet neighborhood spot has a porter that’s richer than any you’ve tried elsewhere.

Ask Locals and Join Beer Communities

Nothing beats word-of-mouth recommendations from people who live and breathe the local beer culture. Join Facebook groups like “Indianapolis Craft Beer Lovers” or “Indy Beer Enthusiasts.” These communities are full of passionate individuals who share tasting notes, event announcements, and honest opinions. Post a simple question: “What’s one underrated brewery in Indy that everyone should try?” You’ll get a flood of thoughtful replies.

Attend local beer events like the Indiana Beer Week festival, the Indy Beer Expo, or neighborhood taproom crawls. These gatherings bring together brewers, fans, and media in one place. Talk to brewers directly. Ask them what they’re most proud of brewing this season. Many will point you to their lesser-known projects or collaborations that aren’t heavily marketed but are deeply beloved by regulars.

Track Seasonal and Limited Releases

One hallmark of a top brewery is its ability to innovate and surprise. The best breweries in Indianapolis don’t just rely on their flagship beers—they build excitement around limited releases. Look for breweries that regularly introduce seasonal brews, barrel-aged variants, or one-off collaborations. For example, a brewery might release a pumpkin ale infused with locally harvested spices in October, or a barrel-aged imperial stout with vanilla and cacao nibs in December.

Follow breweries on social media to stay updated on release dates. Many use Instagram Stories to announce “dropping at noon” or “first pour Saturday.” These releases often sell out quickly, so planning ahead is essential. A brewery that consistently produces high-quality limited beers demonstrates creativity, skill, and confidence in their brewing program.

Consider Location and Accessibility

While flavor and quality are paramount, location and accessibility play a role in your overall experience. Indianapolis is a sprawling city, so consider proximity to your base. Downtown, Fountain Square, and Broad Ripple are dense with breweries, making them ideal for walking tours. If you’re staying near the airport or in the northern suburbs, you might prioritize breweries in those areas.

Also, check parking availability, public transit access, and whether the brewery offers bike racks or ride-share drop-offs. A great beer can be ruined by a 20-minute walk from a poorly lit parking lot. Many top breweries are located in repurposed industrial spaces with outdoor patios, live music, and food trucks—factors that enhance the visit beyond the glass.

Best Practices

Prioritize Quality Over Popularity

Just because a brewery is the most Instagrammed or has the longest line doesn’t mean it’s the best. Some establishments thrive on marketing and aesthetics rather than brewing excellence. Focus on breweries that prioritize flavor, consistency, and craftsmanship. Look for those that brew in-house rather than contract-brewing or sourcing pre-made beer. A true craft brewery controls every step of the process—from grain selection to packaging.

Support Independent and Locally Owned Operations

Independent breweries reinvest in their communities. They hire locally, source ingredients regionally, and often sponsor youth sports teams, art shows, or food drives. Choosing a locally owned brewery over a corporate chain or out-of-state brand amplifies your impact. Use the Brewers Association’s “Independent Craft Brewer” seal as a quick identifier—it’s displayed on cans and tap handles of certified independent operations.

Drink Seasonally and Experiment

Don’t get stuck in a flavor rut. One of the joys of craft beer is the ever-changing lineup. Try a wheat beer in spring, a pale ale in summer, a brown ale in fall, and a porter in winter. Many Indianapolis breweries design their calendars around the seasons, using fresh, local ingredients like peaches, cherries, or maple syrup. Experimenting broadens your palate and helps you discover new favorites you didn’t know you’d love.

Engage with the Staff

Taproom staff are often brewers’ assistants, former homebrewers, or beer educators. Don’t hesitate to ask questions: “What’s the story behind this beer?” or “What food pairs well with this sour?” Their insights can transform a simple drink into a memorable experience. A brewery that empowers its staff to educate guests is one that values customer connection over transactional sales.

Bring a Group or Go Solo—Both Are Valid

Brewery visits are social by nature, but they’re also deeply personal. Going with friends allows for shared discovery and tasting flights. Going alone lets you linger, reflect, and fully absorb the atmosphere. Many Indianapolis taprooms have communal tables, board games, or quiet corners perfect for solo visitors. There’s no right way to enjoy a brewery—only the way that feels authentic to you.

Practice Responsible Consumption

Drinking responsibly enhances the experience. Pace yourself. Use water between samples. Consider splitting a flight with a friend to try more varieties without overindulging. Many breweries offer non-alcoholic options like house-made sodas or kombucha, so you can still enjoy the ambiance without alcohol. Respect the space, the staff, and other guests. A positive, mindful approach ensures the craft beer culture in Indianapolis remains welcoming and sustainable.

Leave Honest Reviews

After your visit, take five minutes to leave a thoughtful review on Untappd, Google, or Yelp. Mention specific beers, the service, the vibe, and whether you’d return. Constructive feedback helps other beer lovers and encourages breweries to maintain standards. Avoid vague comments like “it was good.” Instead, say: “The Midnight Rye IPA had perfect balance—citrusy hops with a subtle roastiness that lingered. Staff recommended the smoked porter, which blew me away.” Specificity matters.

Tools and Resources

Untappd (Mobile App and Website)

Untappd is the most comprehensive tool for tracking and discovering breweries in Indianapolis. With over 10,000 check-ins from local users, it offers real-time data on what’s on tap, user ratings, and trending beers. Use the “Near Me” feature to find breweries within walking distance. Filter by beer style, ABV, or rating. Save your favorite spots to a custom list for future visits. The app also integrates with social media, so you can share your discoveries instantly.

Google Maps and Local Search

Google Maps is invaluable for planning brewery tours. Search “best breweries in Indianapolis” and sort by “Highest Rated.” Click on individual listings to read reviews, see photos, check hours, and view menus. Many breweries now list their full tap list online, so you can preview what’s available before you arrive. Use the “Open Now” filter to avoid arriving at a closed location.

BeerAdvocate and RateBeer

Though less user-friendly than Untappd, BeerAdvocate and RateBeer offer in-depth beer ratings and brewery profiles compiled by a global community of enthusiasts. These platforms are especially useful for comparing beer styles across regions. For example, you can see how Indianapolis’s IPA compares to those from Portland or Denver. Look for breweries with consistent high scores across multiple beer types.

Indianapolis Beer Trail Map

The Indianapolis Beer Trail, promoted by the Indiana Brewers Guild, offers a downloadable or printable map highlighting over 50 participating breweries. Many offer a stamp card system—collect stamps from different locations and redeem them for merchandise or discounts. This is a fun, structured way to explore the city’s diversity. The map also includes brewery types (e.g., nano, micro, brewpub) and amenities like food service and outdoor seating.

Local Event Calendars

Check out event calendars from Visit Indy, Indy Week, and IndyStar for brewery-related events. These include taproom anniversary parties, beer and food pairings, live music nights, and charity fundraisers. Attending these events often gives you access to exclusive releases or behind-the-scenes tours.

Brewery Tours and Shuttle Services

Several companies offer guided brewery tours in Indianapolis, including Indy Brew Bus and Beer Bike Indy. These services handle transportation, provide historical context, and often include tasting flights. They’re ideal for first-time visitors or groups who want a curated experience without the logistics. Some tours focus on specific neighborhoods, like Fountain Square or the Mass Ave district, allowing for deep dives into regional styles.

Beer Subscription Boxes and Local Retailers

Subscriptions from local shops like Beer Run Indy or Tap Room Market deliver curated selections of Indianapolis brews to your door. These boxes often include tasting notes and brewery stories, helping you learn about local brands even if you can’t visit in person. Many also offer virtual tasting events with brewers—another way to connect with the community.

Real Examples

Sun King Brewery – The Pioneer

Sun King is often credited with kickstarting Indianapolis’s craft beer renaissance in 2009. With two locations—downtown and in the northeast—Sun King combines large-scale production with a community-first ethos. Their flagship Osiris Amber Ale remains a regional favorite, but their innovation shines in limited releases like the “Bourbon Barrel Aged Vanilla Bean Stout” and “Grapefruit Gose.” Sun King hosts weekly live music, offers a rotating food truck lineup, and partners with local artists for can designs. Their commitment to transparency—posting detailed brewing logs and ingredient sources online—sets a high standard for the region.

Upland Brewing Company – The Consistent Innovator

Founded in Bloomington but with a major Indianapolis taproom, Upland has earned national acclaim for its sour ales and farmhouse ales. Their “Lemon Wheat” is a perennial bestseller, but their “Brett Saison” and “Tart Cherry Sour” showcase advanced techniques and bold flavor profiles. Upland’s taproom features a large outdoor patio, live jazz on weekends, and a menu of elevated pub fare. They’re also pioneers in sustainable brewing, using solar panels and water recycling systems. Their collaboration with local fruit growers for seasonal sour releases exemplifies true farm-to-glass philosophy.

Flat 12 Bierwerks – The Experimental Powerhouse

Located in the heart of Broad Ripple, Flat 12 is known for pushing boundaries. Their “Peanut Butter Cup Porter” and “Tropical IPA” have become cult favorites, but their most daring offerings include “Pumpkin Pie Sour” and “Coffee & Donut Stout.” They regularly collaborate with local bakeries and chocolatiers, resulting in beers that taste like dessert. The taproom is vibrant, with colorful murals and a rotating art gallery. Flat 12’s “Brewmaster Series” invites customers to vote on experimental recipes, making them active participants in the brewing process.

Champion Brewing Company – The Neighborhood Gem

Don’t overlook Champion, a small but fiercely beloved brewery in the south side of Indianapolis. What they lack in size, they make up for in passion. Their “Rye IPA” and “Blackberry Wheat” are brewed in small batches using locally sourced fruit. Champion doesn’t have a large marketing budget, but their loyal following speaks volumes. The taproom feels like a community living room—friendly, unpretentious, and always welcoming. Their “Brewer’s Choice” flight lets you sample four rotating experimental beers, offering a rare glimpse into the creative process.

Wicked Weed – The Out-of-Towner Making Waves

Though originally from Asheville, North Carolina, Wicked Weed’s Indianapolis location has become a standout. They specialize in wild ales and sour beers, with a dedicated barrel room and aging cellar. Their “Pernicious IPA” and “Lush Life Sour” are must-tries. The taproom features a large beer garden, fire pits, and a menu of gourmet tacos and charcuterie. Their presence in Indy signals the city’s growing appeal to national craft beer brands—a sign of its credibility in the broader industry.

FAQs

What is the most popular brewery in Indianapolis?

Sun King Brewery is widely regarded as the most popular due to its long-standing presence, wide distribution, and consistent quality. However, popularity doesn’t always equal “best.” Many locals consider Upland, Flat 12, or Champion to offer more unique or refined experiences.

Are Indianapolis breweries family-friendly?

Yes, many are. Most taprooms welcome children and offer high chairs, non-alcoholic drinks, and outdoor spaces. Some even host family game nights or craft activities on weekends. Always check the brewery’s website or call ahead to confirm their policies.

Do I need to make reservations to visit a brewery in Indianapolis?

Reservations are rarely required for taproom visits, but they’re recommended for large groups (8+ people) or special events. Some breweries host ticketed tasting events or dinner pairings that require advance booking.

Which neighborhoods have the highest concentration of breweries?

Downtown, Broad Ripple, Fountain Square, and Mass Ave are the most densely packed with breweries. Each has its own character: downtown is urban and bustling, Broad Ripple is trendy and lively, Fountain Square is artsy and eclectic, and Mass Ave blends history with modern flair.

Can I buy Indianapolis craft beer outside the city?

Yes. Many Indianapolis breweries distribute throughout Indiana and neighboring states. Look for their cans or kegs in local liquor stores, grocery chains, and specialty beer shops. Some even ship via online retailers (where legal).

How do I know if a brewery is truly craft?

Look for the Brewers Association’s “Independent Craft Brewer” seal. True craft breweries are small (under 6 million barrels annually), independent (less than 25% owned by a non-craft entity), and traditional (brewing beer using traditional or innovative ingredients and fermentation methods).

What’s the best time of year to visit Indianapolis breweries?

Spring and fall offer the most pleasant weather for outdoor seating and events. Beer Week in June is a major highlight, with special releases and brewery tours. Winter brings cozy barrel-aged stouts and holiday-themed brews. Summer is ideal for refreshing sour ales and fruited lagers.

Are there any brewery tours available in Indianapolis?

Yes. Companies like Indy Brew Bus and Beer Bike Indy offer guided tours with transportation, tasting flights, and historical commentary. Private group tours can also be arranged through many breweries directly.

Conclusion

Finding the best breweries in Indianapolis isn’t about checking off the most names on a list—it’s about cultivating a deeper connection to the city’s culture, creativity, and community. The craft beer scene here is alive, evolving, and deeply rooted in local identity. By defining your preferences, using trusted resources, engaging with brewers, and visiting with curiosity, you’ll uncover not just great beer, but stories, friendships, and unforgettable experiences.

Remember, the “best” brewery is the one that makes you feel something—whether it’s the bold complexity of a barrel-aged stout, the laughter shared over a flight of sours, or the quiet satisfaction of discovering a hidden gem tucked into a quiet neighborhood. Indianapolis offers all of this and more. So grab a glass, explore with intention, and let the beer lead you to places you didn’t know you were looking for.